| Sport | Individual Titles (Last) |
| Women's Cross Country | 1 | | (1998, Katie McGregor) |
| Men's Golf | 3 | | (1947, Dave Barclay) |
| Men's Gymnastics | 26 | | (2003, Andrew DiGiore, vault) |
| Women's Gymnastics | 6 | | (2004, Elise Ray, uneven bars) |
| Women's Rowing | 1 | | (2001, Second Varsity Eight, Melanie Duncan, Petra Juzwishin,
Sera Coppolino, Sophie Roberge, Liz Nelson, Julie Brescoll,
Kristine Johns, Katie Reynolds, coxswain Corinn Cunningham) |
| Men's Swimming and Diving | 157 | | (120 individual -- last: 2008, Alex Vanderkaay,
400-yard individual medley)
(37 relay -- last: 2004, 800-meter freestyle relay,
Peter Vanderkaay, Davis Tarwater, Andrew Hurd, Dan Ketchum) |
| Women's Swimming and Diving | 11 | | (10 individual -- last: 2008, Emily Brunemann,
1,650-yard freestyle)
(1 relay -- last: 1995, 400-yard medley relay,
Talor Bendel, Megan Gillam, Rachel Gustin, Alecia Humphrey) |
| Men's Tennis | 2 | | (1982, Michael Leach) |
| Men's Indoor Track and Field | 11 | | (9 individual -- last: 2007, Jeff Porter, 60-meter hurdles)
(2 relay -- 2005, distance medley relay, Rondell Ruff,
Stann Waithe, Andrew Ellerton, Nate Brannen) |
| Men's Outdoor Track and Field | 34 | | (34 individual -- last: 2007, Andrew Ellerton, 800-meter run)
(0 relay) |
| Women's Indoor Track and Field | 5 | | (2 individual -- last: 2008, Tiffany Ofili, 60-meter hurdles)
(3 relay -- last: 2005, distance medley relay, Nicole Edwards,
Sierra Hauser-Price, Theresa Feldkamp, Lindsey Gallo) |
| Women's Outdoor Track and Field | 4 | | (4 individual -- last: 2008, Geena Gall, 800-meter run;
Tiffany Ofili, 100-meter hurdles)
(0 relay) |
| Wrestling | 19 | | (2005, Ryan Bertin, 157 pounds) |
Totals: Men's Sports 252; Women's Sports 28 |